He was ordained there as co-pastor to Samuel Price in 1753, and became sole pastor on 2 January 1757.

For a short while, he was co-pastor at the Union Chapel with the Rev. Thomas Lewis (1844-1852), but thereafter sole pastor for forty years (1852-92).

Cecil Williams remained sole pastor until 1999, when Rev. Douglass Fitch was named co-Pastor.

The co-pastorate was dissolved in 1908 when Thomas Spurgeon resigned for reasons of health, and Brown accepted the role of sole pastor.

On Bassnett's death on 22 July 1744 Brekell became sole pastor.

After Hotham's death the following May, Cappe became the sole pastor to the congregation and remained in this position until his death.

Lawrence died on 1 October, and Fordyce became sole pastor.

Mr. Jones died in 1898 and Effie continued on as the sole pastor for six more years.

In 1904, she was called again to the church in Waterloo where she was the sole pastor until 1916.

McKinney stepped down in 2009, leaving Nancy Petty as the church's sole pastor.