A reluctant smile tugged at the corner of his mouth.

As always, the contradiction in her brought a reluctant smile to his lips.

The thought almost succeeded in drawing a reluctant smile out of him.

He glanced down at me, and a reluctant smile curved the wide mouth.

From the corner of his eye he saw a reluctant smile come out on Judy's face.

With a reluctant smile, he shook his head and kept walking.

The engineer shrugged him away, but managed a reluctant smile.

A reluctant smile tugged at the edge of her mouth.

His lips twisted, but finally settled on a reluctant smile.

One corner of his mouth lifted in a reluctant smile.