First, the record demonstrates that a filter can prevent minors from seeing all pornography, not just pornography posted to the Web from America.

In order to prevent minors and others from accessing the site improperly, Fletcher charged members a $10 monthly fee to have access to the site.

The states' arguments that their laws prevent minors from ordering wine online also do not impress vineyard owners.

He likened the township's action to "killing fleas with a sledgehammer," and said that the answer to preventing minors from smoking should start at home.

"But isn't there a law preventing minors from working for bookies?"

"Selling liquor is a privilege, and we expect a business to do what it can to prevent minors from drinking," he said.

Very little is done to prevent minors from betting, he said.

He said the law "failed to employ the least restrictive means" in preventing minors from using the lines.

The proposed law also requires merchants to take steps preventing minors from buying it, like they must do with the sale of cigarettes.

The only exceptions are for preventing minors from watching adult content and for child pornography.