It received mostly positive reviews from television critics, who praised the episode for its satire on American politics.

He did, however, praise the episode for being original.

Critics praised the episode, being one of the best reviewed episodes of the season.

Gerald So also praised the episode, but stated that the tone seemed a little too serious compared to the rest of the series.

He praised the episode, saying it "did just about everything it needed to do.

Wilson praised the episode for its cultural references, calling them "true greatness".

He praised the episode scheduled for tomorrow night as "the best one in the series so far."

The review praised the episode, and wrote that "The animation continues to be fantastic."

"Boys' Club" received positive to fair reviews, with some commentators praising the episode for better developing the show's supporting characters.

The New York Times largely praised the episode in its preview/review.