In the first moment of mutual surprise, her gaze met mine.

To their mutual surprise and delight, he had begun dating her again some years after the divorce.

This was to the mutual surprise of both armies, which were both on the move and not in battle order.

Both sides froze in mutual surprise for a moment.

To their mutual surprise, Maria and Larry realize that they couldn't care less.

Then Jim noticed, to our mutual surprise, that each is also a love story anyway.

To their mutual surprise, they found Elspeth seated on the top step.

After an exchange of mutual surprise, the waitress offered to call him if she moved again.

She became Elizabeth's companion, rather than servant, to their mutual surprise.

Perhaps to their mutual surprise, she was moved by her daughter's work.