Rickles mentions him fondly in his biography, "I was fortunate to find a manager who really cared.

His daughters are not mentioned by name in Paullin's biography of Rodgers.

Indeed, this event is not even mentioned in Clarke's biography.

She is mentioned in Prentice's biography (though not by her first name) as living with them in Middletown.

This event is mentioned in Ibn Hisham's biography of Muhammad, and other historical books.

But no such incident is mentioned in Sheriden's detailed biography, or in Broomhall's account.

However, Eginhard does not mention it in his biography of the Emperor.

Welch also points out that the story was not mentioned in the Ibn Ishaq's biography of Muhammad.

This event is also mentioned in Ibn Hisham's biography of Muhammad.

She met Suchtelen and mentioned in her biography that: