It was Pujols' 25th game-winning hit of the season.
"I can count the number of times on my hand I've had a game-winning hit," said Brogna, who is now 11 for his last 25.
Now both have game-winning hits in extra innings in this series.
Nobody figured that the game-winning hit would come off a knuckleball at about 75 miles an hour.
Rodriguez, who has just one home run this season, could use a game-winning hit, too.
One out later, Mack singled to center for his second game-winning hit of the series.
He also led the Giants in game-winning hits with 13.
It was Konerko's second game-winning hit of the week.
He has four game-winning hits in the last nine games.
Bass then stole second and scored on Walling's first game-winning hit of the season.