What should they find incredible, since they believed no longer in a rational universe?

There was much in the story that an average listener might have found incredible.

Magic he found incredible; therefore it didn't really bother him.

Much of what he said that night I found incredible.

Forbin found that incredible, and it filled him with frustrated anger.

"What I find incredible is that here in Connecticut not many people know about this story," he said.

Also, as they had told him, the police usually drove alone, which he found somewhat incredible.

But what we find incredible is the way that people - right up to the early 2000s!

"I find that incredible in a member of this family."

"I'm certain you of all people find that incredible."