The court also endorsed an objective test on policy grounds.
A court recently endorsed one city's resistance to the towers.
"The court cannot endorse either of these proposals," she wrote.
The court also endorsed the right of unmarried couples to live together.
But the chief justice noted pointedly that the court had never endorsed such an approach.
The court neither endorsed abortion nor declared that one side had the superior moral claim.
Courts have not endorsed those positions, but the group continues to encourage peasants to occupy land.
If courts endorse Puerto 80's legal arguments, it would call into question the legitimacy of all such seizures.
It was the first time the court had endorsed such busing into the suburbs as a means of achieving desegregation.
The court endorsed the $1.93 billion as "reasonable."