The Pirates tied the score with in the eighth on Barry Bonds's seventh homer, off Tim Burke.
The Pirates tied the score in the second on a double by Don Slaught and a one-out single by King.
He was charged with an error for dropping the throw, the Pirates tied the score at 3-3 and then won the game against the bullpen in the eighth.
After Boston College opened up a 37-33 lead, the Pirates tied it again at 37-37 on two free throws by Walker.
The Pirates tied the game in the ninth when Reds relief pitcher Rawly Eastwick walked in the tying run with two out.
In the bottom of the first, the Pirates tied the game at one.
The Mets supported Jones (2-3) with a run on a bases-loaded balk in the second, but the Pirates tied the score, 1-1, in the third.
Zeile moved to first base in the seventh, with Jason Phillips catching relievers who allowed the Pirates to tie the score at 7-7.
The Pirates tied it in the fifth when José Lind, better known for his defense, hit a solo homer.
Justice's throwing error in the fourth game of the playoff with Pittsburgh enabled the Pirates to tie the game, which they won in 10 innings, 3-2.