Others Hampered Carl Haynes, Mr. Feinstein's successor at the teamsters, is less visible and represents only 21,000 workers.

Carl Haynes, a former manager at the city's Housing Authority, has served as vice president for about a decade.

Among them was Carl Haynes, president of Teamsters Local 232, which represents the school safety officers.

Carl Haynes, Local 237's president, said he had obtained a side agreement allowing negotiations to continue under the old contract for a possible 1 percent productivity-based wage increase.

One of them is Carl Haynes, president of a New York City local, which, with 24,000 members, is the teamsters' largest.

"He's been right on the issues," said Carl Haynes, president of Teamsters Local 237, a Manhattan-based local with 25,000 members.

Carl Haynes, the president of Teamsters Local 237, which represents the school safety officers, said he had not been briefed on the plan.

Carl Haynes, president of Teamsters Local 237, said: "It provides us with more cover than we already have.

In rebuttal, Carl Haynes, vice president of Local 237, said the East 57th Street apartment, that was leased from 1984 to 1991, was owned by the union.

Carl Haynes, president of Teamsters Local 237, which represents 10,000 city workers, did not see the district council's contract as a model.